What do you think of the iPad?

Technology and opinion, because you care.

Friday, January 15, 2010

Hello Moto

I’ve been using the Droid on Verizon for a month or two now. Because I am much too lazy to write up an actually review, I’ll just sum up what I love, and what I hate, about both Android and the Droid itself.
Pros:
  • Multitasking. Oh GOD multitasking. Opening Pandora and starting up some music, then opening the browser. While the webpage loads, I open up Messaging and send a text. As that is sending, I check up on Twitter, and then look at my Facebook newsfeed. And it all keeps going. The music plays, the webpage finishes loading, the message sends, and I update my status. I could most likely live without this, but that wouldn’t be so pleasant. Honestly, the main luxury of it is having internet radio or something of that sort play in the background. Also part of this is the notifications panel, which is a great way to make everything that is going available to you quickly.
  • Open Source. At first I didn’t quite think I would find this so amazing. However, allowing develops to change how the system works can be great. Different keyboards and file browsers are pretty handy. If the OS doesn’t do something how you want it to, there is an app for that (sorry). That isn’t always the case with the iPhone (AHHH COMPARISONS). This ties into the notifications bar as well. Having WeatherBug always show the temperature is actually one of the best little things about the phone. Widgets are nice too, but more on that later.
  • Facebook. I’m most definitely not talking about the app, but rather the contact integration. Scrolling through your contacts to see all your friends and their Facebook information is just awesome. And being able to see their profile in a tap or two is a nice touch. However, it does seem to have a problem with one of my friends, and lists their name as someone else. I’m sure a minute or two of messing with my friendslist on Facebook could fix that, but nothing on the phone would.
  • Verizon. Call quality is great. 3G almost always works just perfectly, and I haven’t had any major issues with the network. Not much else to say about that.
  • The Build. While I’ll touch more on this below, I am actually quite impressed with the Droid. Metal body, nice and solid slider, and best of all, it is heavy. This beast of a phone just feels like a rock. This son of a bitch makes me feel like I am carrying a powerful device.
  • Navigation. I don’t really need to explain how great this is. It’s accurate, shows street view, runs in the background, and works quickly. Oh, and it’s free. FREE.
Cons:
  • The Mixed Bag. If the platform as a whole has one major flaw, it’s that it has to adapt to so many different devices. 1.6 over here, Sense UI over there, 2.1 on the N1, 2.0 on the Droid, and quite frankly I think that it is a mess for developers and consumers. It’s frustrating to download and app and have it literally not display correctly or even work at all on your phone. When 2.1 comes to the Droid I am not sure how it is going to handle those live wallpapers— it simply doesn’t have the 1 GHz processor of the Nexus 1. I don’t have to explain where that will go. It just makes a mess. Frankly, I think Apple, or even Palm (at least right now), have it right: they control everything so that the experience is always as good as they want it to be.
  • The Build. I said I’d mention more later, and this is it. I’m on my third Droid. The first one had dust under the screen. The second was build poorly, so much so that the keyboard would open in my pocket, and it also got some dust under the screen. This one, the third, is probably destined to end up with dust under the screen as well. No matter how well you build something, it has problems, but it is annoying to deal with all these issues. Luckily I haven’t had to deal with the infamous battery cover, but when I do, I can’t imagine I’ll be too thrilled to have to come up with some sort of fix. It might seem weird to say I love it here, and hate it there, but it’s true.
  • The Look. When you turn on an iPhone, you just feel like it’s elegant. When you power up an Android phone, you are confronted with a crowded home screen and an ugly lock screen. That’s okay (and the home screen does look better in 2.1), but the UI can actually become a barrier. There are many situations when you need multiple taps to do something simple, and sometimes you simply cannot find out how to do something. It isn’t a huge issue, just an annoyance that could be straightened out. Way too much is hidden under a long press or in the second layer of the menu screen.
  • Facebook. Okay, I said I loved the integration but had some issues. After some work I figured out what that was. If I sync my Google contacts with my Mac Address Book, along with my phone, it won’t update Facebook information correctly. My contacts stopped updating, and some of their names switched around. The only fix was to delete the Facebook info and start again. And did I mention that the app itself doesn’t seem to want to pull down notifications due to some error? It would be nice to troubleshoot this, but I can’t because the error message is just cryptic numbers and talks about line errors.
  • Minor Things. Multitouch is the biggest annoyance to me. Just put it in. Zooming in and out on webpages can become time consuming and unweildly in certain cases. Maps desperately needs it as well. It would be handy in Gmail as well. While the Gmail app is fantastic at emulating the webmail experience and then some, it fails when it comes to reading HTML mail. The view is too zoomed in and you have to load pictures manually every time. Where is the option to have it done automatically for certain addresses? And one thing that annoys me about icons (besides their resolution being off in most cases), is that there isn’t enough room for characters on the home screen. While “Twidriod” shows up fine, when I bought the paid version, it now says “Twidroid P-“, with the P beginning to fade, because it can’t fit the whole “PRO” suffix.
  • Open Source. It’s easy to say that all 100,000 apps in the Apple App Store aren’t exactly quality. It’s even easier to say that many of the 10,000 apps in the Android Market definitely aren’t either. It’s free to develop for. Really, you can just go ahead and download the SDK on the website and get going. That’s great for first timers or those willing to start up a new developing business of sorts, but it hurts the consumer in some ways. When I search something, I shouldn’t have to sift through three pages of garbage apps to find something worthwhile. At least you can return something within 24 hours if you don’t like it. Also related to the market: due to the fact that you are limited to internal storage for apps, many aren’t that large, and as such you won’t find any assortment of amazing games. That’s also related to some devices having limited hardware (see above). This is supposed to change in the near future, but remember that because downloads are over the air or wifi (there is no computer software, obviously), downloading some huge application could be troublesome. \
  • Multimedia. I put two or three movies on my phone. Not the best idea. After waiting for the file to sync, then removing it because it wasn’t compatible, then syncing again, I realized that it won’t save your spot. And there isn’t really a video play as much as a plugin in the Gallery that lets you view movies. Oh and why did I say sync? You don’t sync. You copy, because there is no desktop software and everything is drag and drop. There is always something like DoubleTwist, but that doesn’t actually work all the well. It’s a pain. And if you take a cool video, good luck making it play on your computer. The weird file type wasn’t even recognized by VLC.
Android isn’t bad. It also isn’t perfect. All of the problems I listed are really simple things that could be fixed with some software updates, and don’t seriously hamper the experience. For the most part, I can’t see that there is anything that would make me tell someone not to get it. However, anyone getting an Android run device needs to understand something. It isn’t an iPhone. You will need to change settings and get your hands dirty to make it work how you want to. As James DeBragga of Microsoft said, it’s like a free puppy that needs training.

3 comments:

  1. I have the LG EnV1 and my contract ends, letting me upgrade, in February. The Android seems interesting, but I don't think I could afford it, and from the sounds of the review, it may not be the best phone to buy. I like the fact that there is so much you can do on it, but it makes me wonder how it will hold up. The dust under the screen must be pretty annoying, and that is another thing I'll keep in mind. Would you rather have an iPhone or would you keep your current phone?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Honestly, I've seen a pattern with reviews of the Droid. While many people are generally listing more grievances than things they love, they always recommend it. Right now I know that the Droid is the second best phone on the market, behind the iPhone. Would I rather have the iPhone, though? I'm not sure. I miss the better apps and multimedia support, but multitasking, Verizon, the keyboard, and more custimization are also important. I could go either way. For you, I'd recommend the enV3, which is probably Verizon's best feature phone besides the enV touch.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i have the glyde and i always end up breaking it somehow. i really want a better phone so i can go on the internet and do more things. this phone sounds really great but i would be scared i would break it.

    ReplyDelete